As news breaks about a tragic event or its anniversary rolls around, it's natural for people today to take to social media to voice their opinions, memories and condolences. This is the age we live in, where it's almost like if you don't comment on something, you're a terrible person. Social media has completely changed how we learn and handle tragedy.
Of course, this is the point of social media, to allow people from all over the world to connect and discuss whatever is on their minds in real time. With everyone talking about a certain topic and hashtags trending on Twitter, it's easy to feel the appeal, not to mention pressure, to send out a tweet really quickly so that you have a good chance of a lot of people seeing it. But if you don't take a good amount of time to think about how people will perceive your tweet, you could find yourself embroiled in a bit of a PR nightmare.
Brands are notorious for doing just that. If there's a major event grabbing headlines or a hashtag trending on Twitter, you can be sure that no matter how horrific it is, one or more brands will take this opportunity to promote themselves, because that's the point of brands being on Twitter. Most of us usually just think to ourselves that these promotional tweets are icky or inappropriate. But one man has taken it upon himself to document the way brands were handling the anniversary of September 11th.
Mike Monteiro, the design director of the design studio Mule, responded to many of the brands tweeting to commemorate the 13th anniversary of the September 11 attacks yesterday. Many of the brands were promoting their own discounts for that day. Consequently, many of Monteiro's comments were predictably irreverent and sarcastic toward the brand, feigning an earnest appreciation of the brands' thoughts on the day.
I’d love to engage with you, @HayworthPR. You guys did some work for Ray Rice, right? Any special discounts today? #neverforget
— Mike Monteiro (@monteiro) September 11, 2014
Tell you what @WeberGrills, you gimme a good discount on a grill and I’ll put my brother’s ashes in with the charcoal. #neverforget — Mike Monteiro (@monteiro) September 11, 2014
Thank you @Applebees. When we pulled Mother’s body out of the wreckage we dragged it to Applebees. And you guys gave us free sodas.
— Mike Monteiro (@monteiro) September 11, 2014
Sometimes, Monteiro just retweeted messages from brands to let them speak for themselves.
#NeverForget #NeverForgetSeptember11 pic.twitter.com/LYGdUtcgDq — spaces kennebunkport (@spaceskport) September 11, 2014
Today is a day of commemoration and quiet reflection. We will #NeverForget. pic.twitter.com/3HIdjL0tCr
— Ty Inc (@TyInc) September 11, 2014
For every victim. For every hero. For every person who was lost but never forgotten. Beretta Nation is United. pic.twitter.com/Z1F4kLjAMj — BERETTA (@Beretta_USA) September 11, 2014
Monteiro even inspired some people to send in ads they stumbled upon.
Mini Muffins. #NeverForget911 #marriott @GOPTeens @aterkel @RodneyAnon @dogboner @michaelianblack pic.twitter.com/4Cn2vS5RFi — Mike Suade (@suade99) September 11, 2014
However, Monteiro's efforts even backfired on him a little with some Twitter users accusing him of using the campaign to, ironically, serve his own interests.
@monteiro Not to be a dick, Mike; I mean, I agree with your sentiment. But isn't a day-long campaign about this also sorta self-serving? — Aiden Bordner (@aidenbordner) September 12, 2014
Sean Bonner, an entrepreneur and journalist, also retweeted brands' messages in a similar fashion to Monteiro yesterday and told AdWeek, "Brands are not people. Brands do not have emotions or memories or condolences or heartbreak. People have those things, and when a brand tries to jump into that conversation, it's marketing. And in a less emotionally charged environment it's just dumb."
And sometimes, tweeting out an apology can't make what you did go away.
Pro tip for all the brands writing apology tweets for their 9/11 tweets: don’t apologize for how people felt, apologize for your actions.
— Mike Monteiro (@monteiro) September 12, 2014
Example: “We’re sorry we upset you” is not an apology. Try this: “we’re sorry for our poor judgment in shamelessly promoting ourselves.” — Mike Monteiro (@monteiro) September 12, 2014
Looks like emotional intelligence on social media is still on a learning curve.
[H/T AdWeek]